Overproofed Sourdough

It’s happened to us all – those days when you forget you left your sourdough sitting to proof, only to find a giant puff ball that was once an innocent little ball of dough. While we’d all love a miracle solution that would turn back time and make this extra wild dough more manageable, it’s important to remember the basics of troubleshooting overproofed sourdough. Start by understanding how overproofing happens – too much time in the warmth and humidity can cause fermentation to go wild! From there, you can adjust things like temperature and hydration levels to ensure the bread turns out as good (or nearly as good!) as possible. So while these mistakes happen, they certainly don’t mean your baking journey is over. Don’t be afraid of making tweaks and adjustments in order to create the best possible loaf from your overproofed starter.

Overproofed sourdough crumb

Overproofed sourdough is dough that has been left to proof for too long. This means that the yeast has consumed all the available sugars in the dough, and the gluten structure has broken down. The dough becomes sticky, and it loses its elasticity, making it difficult to shape and bake.

Working with overproofed sourdough can be a tricky game of experimentation and adjustment. The ideal crumb of your finished product is dependent on how long the dough was proofed for, and how this affected the rise of your bake – both in development and final texture. Taking extra care when shaping, scoring, and baking your dough is paramount to avoiding a dense, convoluted result instead of light and fluffy perfection.

See the example photo below of what an overproofed crumb looks like (and you can see here what an underproofed sourdough looks like).

Overproofed sourdough bread

Signs of overproofed sourdough

There are several signs that your sourdough bread has been overproofed. These include a sticky and wet dough, a lack of elasticity when shaping, and a flattening of the dough. You may also notice that the dough has a sour smell, indicating that the yeast has consumed all the available sugars.

Overproofed sourdough is a bread-baker’s worst enemy. If you’ve ever seen an over-risen mess of dough peeking out of the loaf pan, you’ll know exactly what we’re talking about. Signs of an overproofed sourdough can be fairly easy to spot – the dough may have grown so much that it’s starting to collapse in on itself, or become extremely thin and fragile. It will often look very glossy too, with well-defined air bubbles throughout. On the other hand, if your dough is dense and heavy or has few visible air bubbles even after baking, it might be underproofed.

How long to overproof sourdough?

The length of time it takes to overproof sourdough depends on several factors, including the temperature of the room, the hydration level of the dough, and the strength of the starter. (Check out our sourdough starter tips page to read even more.) Generally, sourdough bread should be left to proof for 4-12 hours, depending on the recipe. However, if the dough is left to proof for longer than 12 hours, it is likely to become overproofed.

The best way to judge whether your sourdough has been overproofed is by looking at its appearance – if it’s significantly larger than when you started and looks spongey then chances are it’s been overproofing too long! If this is the case, don’t panic – simply start again, paying closer attention to proofing times.

Can you overproof sourdough in the fridge?

Yes, it’s possible to overproof sourdough in the fridge. If left in the fridge for too long, the dough can become over-fermented, resulting in a flat and dense loaf.

Understanding the science of overproofing – what happens to your dough when it’s left for too long

When sourdough is left to proof for too long, the yeast and bacteria consume all the available sugars in the dough, producing alcohol and carbon dioxide. This causes the dough to rise and expand. However, if the dough is left for too long, the gluten structure will begin to break down, resulting in a sticky, unmanageable dough.

Overproofed sourdough is every baker’s worst nightmare. It’s something that isn’t likely to happen on purpose, and if you don’t know how to recognize it – or how to rescue it – you could be doomed to a tough, dense loaf of bread. But understanding the science behind overproofing will help give you the edge and have a much better outcome with fewer second chances. When dough is left for too long, the yeast increases drastically, causing an overproduction of carbon dioxide which leaves the dough deflated and makes it difficult for air pockets to form – that was an easy explanation, right? From there it’s all about knowing what hasn’t worked so you can focus on finding the solution. So go forth and never let dreaded overproofing stand in your way again!

What does overproofed sourdough taste like?

Overproofed sourdough will have a sour, almost alcoholic smell, and a taste that’s similar to that of beer or wine. The texture will be gummy and dense, with large air pockets in the crumb.

What happens if you overproof sourdough

When it comes to baking your own sourdough, overproofing is one misstep you want to avoid – especially if you’re aiming for that perfect rise. Overproofing causes the dough to go flat and deflated once it hits the oven. But what really happens when you overproof? In essence, your dough’s gluten structure has been weakened by the extended fermentation time, leading to an undesirable texture and lack of that signature sourdough “tang”. To combat this, measure out the exact quantity of yeast that your recipe calls for, always keep an eye on your rising dough, and try to stick as close to either room temperature or a couple of degrees higher before putting in the oven.

Scoring overproofed sourdough

Scoring your overproofed sourdough can definitely be a tricky business. Sometimes, no matter how carefully you plan, you end up with a loaf that’s so bubbly and voluminous that it’s hard to slash into it without risking major deflation. You might find yourself standing in front of what looks like a fluffy pillow rather than the impressive blistered bread that you intended to create. Don’t freak out – there are still options! With some simple troubleshooting and an understanding of why this happened in the first place, you can salvage that dough and turn it into something worthy of sharing with friends and family.

Scoring overproofed sourdough can be challenging because the dough will lack structure and will be difficult to handle. However, you can still score the bread to help it rise evenly in the oven. Use a sharp knife or bread lame to score the dough just before baking, making sure not to press too hard and deflate the dough further.

Leave a Comment